Da li je pedofilija zaista zaseban entitet?
Is pedophilia really separated, unique entity?
Konferencijski prilog (Objavljena verzija)
Metapodaci
Prikaz svih podataka o dokumentuApstrakt
Iako je još od klasične psihijatrije smatrana podvrstom seksualne psihopatije,
pedofilija je u važećim nomenklaturama mentalnih poremećaja
Američkog psihijatrijskog udruženja DSM IV (APA,1994) i Svetske zdravstvene
organizacije ICD-10 (WHO, 1992) izdvojena od psihopatije i tretira
se kao zaseban entitet svrstan u kategoriju parafilija. U radu je ispitivana
opravdanost takvog pristupa kroz analizu preklapanja psiholoških i kriminoloških
karakteristika pedofila i psihopata. Utvrđeno je da se one u
potpunosti podudaraju: i na nivou stukture i dinamike ličnosti, defekata u
području ego funkcija i po povišenjima skale psihopatije (pd) na MMPI u
empirijskim istraživanjima, ali i po načinu izvršenja seksualne zlostave dece
i po tipovima učinioca. Podudarnost je očigledna i na konceptualnom planu,
te savremeni dijagnostički modeli psihopatije poput Millonovog, veoma
dobro definišu pedofile.
Zato je zaključeno da je i na teorijskom i na praktičnom nivou neprihvatljivo
odvajanje pe...dofilije od psihopatije. Takvo odvajanje ima negativne
konsekvence na procenu stepena opasnosti i rizika od recidivizma, na odmeravanje
težine i dužine kazni i na izbor (ne)prikladnih vidova tretmana
za ovu kategoriju prestupnika
Paedophilia was considered as a type of sexual psychopathy from classical
psychiatry, in official nomenclatures of mental disorders of American Psychiatric
Association DSM-IV( APA,1994) and World Health Organisation ICD-10 (
WHO,1992), it is labelled as unique entity positioned in category of paraphilia,
quite separate from psychopathy. In this paper, the acceptance of that approach
was tested using analyses of congruency of psychological and criminological
characteristics of two entities: paedophilia and psychopathy. It is established that
paedophilia is completely matched with psychopathy: in structure and dynamic
of personality, in deficits in ego functions and in heighten scale of psychopathy
(pd) in MMPI in empirical researches and in modus operandi of sexual abuse of
children and in type of offenders. Congruency is apparently at a conceptual level
too, as actual diagnostic models of psychopathy are inclined to accurately define
paedophiles.
It is concluded that on th...eoretical and practical levels separation of paedophilia
from psychopathy is unacceptable. Negative consequences of such separation are
serious for prediction of violence, risk of recidivism and decisions about duration
and severity of punishment and (in) appropriate forms of treatment for these
offenders.
Ključne reči:
pedofilija / kriminal / psihopatija / psihološke karakteristike / paedophilia / crime / psychopathy / psychological characteristicsIzvor:
Zbornik radova - „ Smetnje i poremećaji: fenomenologija, prevencija i tretman deo II / Disabilities and Disorders: Phenomenology, Prevention and Treatment Part I I “,Beograd / Belgrade 2010, 2010, 457-470Izdavač:
- Univerzitet u Beogradu – Fakultet za specijalnu edukaciju i rehabilitaciju/ University of Belgrade – Faculty of Special Education and Rehabilitation
Institucija/grupa
rFASPERTY - CONF AU - Kovačević, Jasmina AU - Vučinić, Vesna PY - 2010 UR - http://rfasper.fasper.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/4488 AB - Iako je još od klasične psihijatrije smatrana podvrstom seksualne psihopatije, pedofilija je u važećim nomenklaturama mentalnih poremećaja Američkog psihijatrijskog udruženja DSM IV (APA,1994) i Svetske zdravstvene organizacije ICD-10 (WHO, 1992) izdvojena od psihopatije i tretira se kao zaseban entitet svrstan u kategoriju parafilija. U radu je ispitivana opravdanost takvog pristupa kroz analizu preklapanja psiholoških i kriminoloških karakteristika pedofila i psihopata. Utvrđeno je da se one u potpunosti podudaraju: i na nivou stukture i dinamike ličnosti, defekata u području ego funkcija i po povišenjima skale psihopatije (pd) na MMPI u empirijskim istraživanjima, ali i po načinu izvršenja seksualne zlostave dece i po tipovima učinioca. Podudarnost je očigledna i na konceptualnom planu, te savremeni dijagnostički modeli psihopatije poput Millonovog, veoma dobro definišu pedofile. Zato je zaključeno da je i na teorijskom i na praktičnom nivou neprihvatljivo odvajanje pedofilije od psihopatije. Takvo odvajanje ima negativne konsekvence na procenu stepena opasnosti i rizika od recidivizma, na odmeravanje težine i dužine kazni i na izbor (ne)prikladnih vidova tretmana za ovu kategoriju prestupnika AB - Paedophilia was considered as a type of sexual psychopathy from classical psychiatry, in official nomenclatures of mental disorders of American Psychiatric Association DSM-IV( APA,1994) and World Health Organisation ICD-10 ( WHO,1992), it is labelled as unique entity positioned in category of paraphilia, quite separate from psychopathy. In this paper, the acceptance of that approach was tested using analyses of congruency of psychological and criminological characteristics of two entities: paedophilia and psychopathy. It is established that paedophilia is completely matched with psychopathy: in structure and dynamic of personality, in deficits in ego functions and in heighten scale of psychopathy (pd) in MMPI in empirical researches and in modus operandi of sexual abuse of children and in type of offenders. Congruency is apparently at a conceptual level too, as actual diagnostic models of psychopathy are inclined to accurately define paedophiles. It is concluded that on theoretical and practical levels separation of paedophilia from psychopathy is unacceptable. Negative consequences of such separation are serious for prediction of violence, risk of recidivism and decisions about duration and severity of punishment and (in) appropriate forms of treatment for these offenders. PB - Univerzitet u Beogradu – Fakultet za specijalnu edukaciju i rehabilitaciju/ University of Belgrade – Faculty of Special Education and Rehabilitation C3 - Zbornik radova - „ Smetnje i poremećaji: fenomenologija, prevencija i tretman deo II / Disabilities and Disorders: Phenomenology, Prevention and Treatment Part I I “,Beograd / Belgrade 2010 T1 - Da li je pedofilija zaista zaseban entitet? T1 - Is pedophilia really separated, unique entity? EP - 470 SP - 457 UR - https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rfasper_4488 ER -
@conference{ author = "Kovačević, Jasmina and Vučinić, Vesna", year = "2010", abstract = "Iako je još od klasične psihijatrije smatrana podvrstom seksualne psihopatije, pedofilija je u važećim nomenklaturama mentalnih poremećaja Američkog psihijatrijskog udruženja DSM IV (APA,1994) i Svetske zdravstvene organizacije ICD-10 (WHO, 1992) izdvojena od psihopatije i tretira se kao zaseban entitet svrstan u kategoriju parafilija. U radu je ispitivana opravdanost takvog pristupa kroz analizu preklapanja psiholoških i kriminoloških karakteristika pedofila i psihopata. Utvrđeno je da se one u potpunosti podudaraju: i na nivou stukture i dinamike ličnosti, defekata u području ego funkcija i po povišenjima skale psihopatije (pd) na MMPI u empirijskim istraživanjima, ali i po načinu izvršenja seksualne zlostave dece i po tipovima učinioca. Podudarnost je očigledna i na konceptualnom planu, te savremeni dijagnostički modeli psihopatije poput Millonovog, veoma dobro definišu pedofile. Zato je zaključeno da je i na teorijskom i na praktičnom nivou neprihvatljivo odvajanje pedofilije od psihopatije. Takvo odvajanje ima negativne konsekvence na procenu stepena opasnosti i rizika od recidivizma, na odmeravanje težine i dužine kazni i na izbor (ne)prikladnih vidova tretmana za ovu kategoriju prestupnika, Paedophilia was considered as a type of sexual psychopathy from classical psychiatry, in official nomenclatures of mental disorders of American Psychiatric Association DSM-IV( APA,1994) and World Health Organisation ICD-10 ( WHO,1992), it is labelled as unique entity positioned in category of paraphilia, quite separate from psychopathy. In this paper, the acceptance of that approach was tested using analyses of congruency of psychological and criminological characteristics of two entities: paedophilia and psychopathy. It is established that paedophilia is completely matched with psychopathy: in structure and dynamic of personality, in deficits in ego functions and in heighten scale of psychopathy (pd) in MMPI in empirical researches and in modus operandi of sexual abuse of children and in type of offenders. Congruency is apparently at a conceptual level too, as actual diagnostic models of psychopathy are inclined to accurately define paedophiles. It is concluded that on theoretical and practical levels separation of paedophilia from psychopathy is unacceptable. Negative consequences of such separation are serious for prediction of violence, risk of recidivism and decisions about duration and severity of punishment and (in) appropriate forms of treatment for these offenders.", publisher = "Univerzitet u Beogradu – Fakultet za specijalnu edukaciju i rehabilitaciju/ University of Belgrade – Faculty of Special Education and Rehabilitation", journal = "Zbornik radova - „ Smetnje i poremećaji: fenomenologija, prevencija i tretman deo II / Disabilities and Disorders: Phenomenology, Prevention and Treatment Part I I “,Beograd / Belgrade 2010", title = "Da li je pedofilija zaista zaseban entitet?, Is pedophilia really separated, unique entity?", pages = "470-457", url = "https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rfasper_4488" }
Kovačević, J.,& Vučinić, V.. (2010). Da li je pedofilija zaista zaseban entitet?. in Zbornik radova - „ Smetnje i poremećaji: fenomenologija, prevencija i tretman deo II / Disabilities and Disorders: Phenomenology, Prevention and Treatment Part I I “,Beograd / Belgrade 2010 Univerzitet u Beogradu – Fakultet za specijalnu edukaciju i rehabilitaciju/ University of Belgrade – Faculty of Special Education and Rehabilitation., 457-470. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rfasper_4488
Kovačević J, Vučinić V. Da li je pedofilija zaista zaseban entitet?. in Zbornik radova - „ Smetnje i poremećaji: fenomenologija, prevencija i tretman deo II / Disabilities and Disorders: Phenomenology, Prevention and Treatment Part I I “,Beograd / Belgrade 2010. 2010;:457-470. https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rfasper_4488 .
Kovačević, Jasmina, Vučinić, Vesna, "Da li je pedofilija zaista zaseban entitet?" in Zbornik radova - „ Smetnje i poremećaji: fenomenologija, prevencija i tretman deo II / Disabilities and Disorders: Phenomenology, Prevention and Treatment Part I I “,Beograd / Belgrade 2010 (2010):457-470, https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_rfasper_4488 .